Misfit Patriot Called Out As Fake Catholic In Heated Debate
Host demolishes Misfit Patriot's Catholic credentials after he calls the Church a 'man-made institution,' calling it 'legit heresy' and questioning whether he even knows basic Catholic history.
A heated on-air debate erupted when Misfit Patriot, who claims to be Catholic, stated that the Catholic Church is a 'man-made institution' — a claim the host immediately flagged as heresy. The host challenged Misfit Patriot on basic Catholic doctrine, asking if he even knew what the Council of Florence, the Council of Nicaea, or Vatican II were, implying he had no grounding in the faith he claimed to represent. The host turned to the live chat to prove his point, asking viewers who created the Catholic Church according to Catholic teaching. Chat members including Joey Caravello correctly answered that Jesus Christ founded the Church. The host explained the Catholic belief that Christ renamed Simon as Peter ('the rock') and said 'Upon this rock, I will build my church,' giving Peter the keys to the kingdom of heaven — the moment Catholics believe the Church was founded. The host expressed frustration that Misfit Patriot had been 'talking smack' and agreed to debate without knowing 'the basics of Catholicism.' He suggested Misfit Patriot should just admit he's Jewish and loves Israel rather than 'LARPing' as a Catholic, tying the theological dispute to Misfit Patriot's Zionist political positions. The host argued that while someone can personally be both Catholic and Zionist in their politics, they cannot claim Catholicism as the theological justification for Zionism.